Attaboy at 134 Eldridge doesn't have menu or sign... Tell bartender what flavors you like, they make something custom. Tiny — Maybe 20 people max — And cocktails are incredible.

Go before 8pm or after midnight to get in. Sweet spot around 7pm weeknights. Cocktails $16-18 but worth it. Not pretentious despite how this sounds... Bartenders genuinely cool.

F train to Delancey-Essex, walk south on Eldridge. Look for small door with no sign.